Combined computational and crystallographic study of the oxidised states of [NiFe] hydrogenase

[NiFe] hydrogenases catalyse the reaction H2 <-> 2H(+) + 2e(-). Several states of the enzyme have been observed by spectroscopic methods. Among these, the two most oxidized states, called the unready Ni-A and Ni-SU states, have been especially intriguing, because they take a much longer time to activate than the corresponding ready Ni-B and Ni-SI states. It has recently been suggested that the unready states actually contain a (hydro)peroxide bridge between the Ni and Fe ions, in contrast to the hydroxide bridge in the ready states. In this paper, we use quantum refinement (crystallographic refinement, in which the molecular mechanics [MM] calculations, normally employed to supplement the crystallographic data, are replace by more accurate quantum mechanics [QM] calculations), combined QM/MM calculations, and accurate energy estimates to study the nature of a recent oxidised crystal structure of [NiFe] hydrogenase from Desulfovibrio fructosovorans. We show that the structure contains a mixture of several states in the active site. The experimental data is best explained by structures with a hydroxide bridge but with two of the cysteine ligands (one bridging and one terminal) partly oxidised. When the terminal Cys-543 ligand is oxidised, the sulphur occupies an alternative position, observed in several crystal structures. The Glu-25 residue, that forms a hydrogen bond to this sulphur, also changes position. A peroxide ligand may exist as a minor component in the crystal and the suggested structure is supported by the calculations. We suggest that oxidised states are slow-equilibrium mixtures of structures with a peroxide bound and structures with oxidised Cys residues, and that the former can be activated by replacement of the protonated peroxide with a H-2 or CO ligand, as has been observed in electrochemical experiments. (c) 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.