Of boundaries and metaphysical starting points: why the extended mind cannot be so lightly dismissed

Joel Parthemore

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

Abstract

The extended mind debate is, to large extent, a debate over where and how to locate the boundary between cognitive mind and non-cognitive world. Concepts of “internal” and “external”, taken from the domain of physical volumes, are metaphorical, at best, applied to entities like mind. Strongly held intuitions betray metaphysical starting points that prejudice the debate. If one does not accept these starting points, then the “just obvious” claims made by critics of extended mind are far less clear. The mind/world distinction is, ultimately, a conceptual one, and like most if not all conceptual distinctions, subject to shift over time.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)79-94
JournalTeorema
Volume30
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 2011

Subject classification (UKÄ)

  • Languages and Literature

Free keywords

  • boundary
  • intuitions
  • realism
  • anti-realism
  • enactivism

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Of boundaries and metaphysical starting points: why the extended mind cannot be so lightly dismissed'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.
  • CCS: Centre for Cognitive Semiotics (RJ)

    Lenninger, S. (Researcher), Sonesson, G. (PI), Toyota, J. (Researcher), Brinck, I. (Researcher), Kopp, L. (Researcher), Holmer, A. (Researcher), Karlsson, A. (Researcher), Tayanin, D. (Researcher), Carling, G. (Researcher), Håkansson, G. (Researcher), Blomberg, J. (Researcher), Zlatev, J. (PI), Henningsson, L.-Å. (Researcher), Andrén, M. (Researcher), Sayehli, S. (Researcher), Strandviken, T. (Researcher), Parthemore, J. (Researcher), Persson, T. (Researcher), Cabak Rédei, A. (Researcher), Madsen, E. A. (Researcher), Hornborg, A. (Researcher), Andrén, M. (Researcher), Henningsson, L.-Å. (Researcher), Kopp, L. (Researcher), Tayanin, D. (Researcher) & Toyota, J. (Researcher)

    2009/01/012014/12/31

    Project: Research

Cite this