BCG scarring and improved child survival: a combined analysis of studies of BCG scarring

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

Abstract

Bacillus Calmette–Guérin (BCG) vaccine against tuberculosis (TB) is recommended given at birth in TB-endemic areas. Currently, BCG vaccination programmes use “BCG vaccination coverage by 12 months of age” as the performance indicator. Previous studies suggest that BCG-vaccinated children, who develop a scar, have better overall survival compared with BCG-vaccinated children, who do not develop a scar. We summarized the available studies of BCG scarring and child survival. A structured literature search for studies with original data and analysis of BCG scarring and mortality. Combined analyses on effect of BCG scarring on overall mortality. We identified six studies covering seven cohorts, all from Guinea-Bissau, West Africa, with evaluation of BCG scarring amongst BCG-vaccinated children and follow-up for mortality. Determinants for BCG scarring were BCG strain, intradermal injection route, size of injection wheal, and co-administered vaccines and micronutrients. In a combined analysis, having a BCG scar vs. no BCG scar was associated with a mortality rate ratio (MRR) of 0.61 (95% CI: 0.51–0.74). The proportion with a BCG scar varied from 52 to 93%; the estimated effect of a BCG scar was not associated with the scar prevalence. The effect was strongest in the first (MRR = 0.48 (0.37–0.62)) and second (MRR = 0.63 (0.44–0.92)) year of life, and in children BCG-vaccinated in the neonatal period (MRR = 0.45 (0.36–0.55). The effect was not explained by protection against TB. Confounding and genetic factors are unlikely to explain the strong association between BCG scarring and subsequent survival. Including “BCG scar prevalence” as a BCG vaccination programme performance indicator should be considered. The effect of revaccinating scar-negative children should be studied.

Details

Authors
  • C. S. Benn
  • A. Roth
  • M. L. Garly
  • A. B. Fisker
  • F. Schaltz-Buchholzer
  • A. Timmermann
  • M. Berendsen
  • P. Aaby
Organisations
External organisations
  • Bandim Health Project
  • Danish Serum Institute, Copenhagen
  • University of Southern Denmark
  • Public Health Agency of Sweden
  • Radboud University Medical Center
  • Odense University Hospital
Research areas and keywords

Subject classification (UKÄ) – MANDATORY

  • Pediatrics
  • Infectious Medicine

Keywords

  • Bacille Calmette–Guérin, BCG scar, child survival, nonspecific effects of vaccines
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)614-624
Number of pages11
JournalJournal of Internal Medicine
Volume288
Issue number6
Early online date2020 Apr 16
Publication statusPublished - 2020 Dec
Publication categoryResearch
Peer-reviewedYes