Understanding communicative intentions and semiotic vehicles by children and chimpanzees

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Developmental and comparative studies of the ability to understand communicative intentions using object-choice tasks raise questions concerning the semiotic properties of the communicative signals, and the roles of rearing histories, language and familiarity. We adapted a study by Tomasello, Call, and Gluckman (1997), in which a “helper” indicated the location of a hidden reward to children of three ages (18, 24, and 30 months) and to four chimpanzees, by means of one of four cues: Pointing, Marker, Picture and Replica. For the chimpanzees, we controlled for familiarity by using two helpers, one unfamiliar and one highly familiar. Even 18-months performed well on Pointing and Marker, while only the oldest group clearly succeeded with Picture and Replica. Performance did not correlate with scores for the Swedish Early Communicative Development Inventory (SECDI). While there were no positive results for the chimpanzees on the group level, and no effect of familiarity, two chimpanzees succeeded on Pointing and Marker. Results support proposals of a species difference in understanding communicative intentions, but also highlight the need to distinguish these from the complexity of semiotic vehicles and to consider both factors.

Details

Authors
Organisations
Research areas and keywords

Subject classification (UKÄ) – MANDATORY

  • General Language Studies and Linguistics
  • Zoology
  • Psychology (excluding Applied Psychology)

Keywords

  • Pointing, Object-choice, Indexicality, Conventionality, Familiarity, Iconicity
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)312-329
JournalCognitive Development
Volume28
Issue number3
Publication statusPublished - 2013
Publication categoryResearch
Peer-reviewedYes

Bibliographic note

The information about affiliations in this record was updated in December 2015. The record was previously connected to the following departments: Cognitive Science (015001004), Cognitive Semiotics (015030003), Humanities Lab (015101200), Linguistics and Phonetics (015010003)

Related projects

Sara Lenninger, Göran Sonesson, Junichi Toyota, Ingar Brinck, Lars Kopp, Arthur Holmer, Anastasia Karlsson, Damrong Tayanin, Gerd Carling, Gisela Håkansson, Johan Blomberg, Jordan Zlatev, Lars-Åke Henningsson, Mats Andrén, Susan Sayehli, Teresa Strandviken, Joel Parthemore, Tomas Persson, Anna Cabak Rédei, Elainie Alenkær Madsen, Alf Hornborg, Mats Andrén, Lars-Åke Henningsson, Lars Kopp, Damrong Tayanin & Junichi Toyota

2009/01/012014/12/31

Project: Research

Sara Lenninger, Göran Sonesson, Jordan Zlatev, Mats Andrén, Susan Sayehli, Tomas Persson & Elainie Alenkær Madsen

2009/01/012012/12/31

Project: Research

View all (2)